A guide from Pure Mechanical GroupWritten by a Red Seal plumber in British Columbia

Sizing · Rule of thumb · Updated November 2026

What size water heater you need.

Start with the number of people, then adjust for how you use hot water and what heats it.

Tank size by household

How many people live in the home?
For three people: a 40 to 50 gallon tank (151 to 189 litres). Choose the larger size for an electric or heat pump tank.
PeopleTank sizeIn litres
1 to 230 to 40 gallons114 to 151 L
2 to 340 to 50 gallons151 to 189 L
3 to 450 to 60 gallons189 to 227 L
5 or more60 to 80 gallons227 to 303 L

A rule of thumb in US gallons, the way tanks are sold. Natural Resources Canada says the average Canadian uses about 75 litres of hot water a day at home.

Then adjust

  • Gas recovers faster than electric. A gas burner reheats a tank much more quickly than electric elements, so a gas tank can sit at the low end of the range and an electric one at the high end.
  • Heat pump tanks go up a size. They reheat slowly in heat pump mode. A household that would buy a 50 gallon electric tank usually wants 65 or 80.
  • Count the big draws. A soaker tub, a rain shower or teenagers each justify the next size up.
  • A suite counts as a household. Add its people, or give it its own heater.
  • Check the space. A bigger tank is wider and taller. Measure the doorway and the ceiling before you fall for it.

The number that matters: first-hour rating

Two 50 gallon tanks are not equal. The first-hour rating on the EnerGuide label is how much hot water the heater delivers in an hour starting full, which combines the size of the tank with how fast it reheats. Match it to your busiest hour: the morning when the showers, the dishwasher and the laundry overlap.

How tankless is sized

A tankless heater has no gallons. It is sized by flow: how many litres a minute it can raise from the temperature of the incoming water to the temperature you want. Add up what could run at once. A shower is roughly 6 to 9 litres a minute, a kitchen tap 6, a washing machine about the same.

The catch in B.C. is winter. Incoming water is far colder in January than in August, and the colder it comes in, the less flow the same heater can deliver. A unit that handles two showers in summer may manage one and a tap in winter. Size it for January.

Questions

Is a bigger water heater always better?

No. An oversized tank costs more to buy and keeps more water hot than you use. Size it for your busiest hour, with a little room, not for the one weekend a year the house is full.

Can I replace a 40 gallon tank with a 50?

Usually, if it fits the space and the vent is large enough for the bigger burner. Your installer checks both before recommending the larger size.

Sources

More water heater help

This page is general information, not professional advice for your home. Gas, electrical and plumbing work is regulated in British Columbia. If you are unsure at any point, stop and call a licensed contractor. See the legal disclaimer.