Diagnosis · Typical repair $429 to $959+ · Updated November 2026
Repair or replace.
Most water heater problems are a part, not the tank. Here is how to tell which you have.
By Andrew HendersonRed Seal Plumber
The one rule
If the tank itself is leaking, replace it. A steel tank that has rusted through cannot be patched. Everything else on this page is worth diagnosing first.
Symptom by symptom
| What you notice | Usual cause | Usually |
|---|---|---|
| No hot water, gas | Pilot or igniter, flame sensor or thermocouple, gas control | Repair |
| No hot water, electric | Tripped breaker or high-limit switch, failed element or thermostat | Repair |
| Runs out too soon | Failed lower element, broken dip tube, heavy sediment, or a tank that is now too small | Repair, or resize |
| Rumbling or popping | Sediment on the bottom of the tank boiling as it heats | Flush. On an old tank, a warning |
| Rusty hot water | A spent anode rod, or the tank lining failing | New anode if the tank is young. Replace if it is old |
| Rotten egg smell, hot water only | Bacteria reacting with the anode rod | Repair: flush and change the anode |
| Relief valve dripping | Thermal expansion with nowhere to go, high pressure, or a worn valve | Repair. Never cap it |
| Water at the base | A fitting, valve or the relief pipe above it. Or the tank | Find the source first. How |
When a repair stops making sense
- The heater is past its typical life: 10 to 13 years for a gas tank, about 20 for tankless
- The repair is a large share of the cost of a new heater
- It is the second or third repair in a couple of years
- The installation has code problems that have to be fixed anyway
- You are in a Vancouver house and would rather choose the replacement than have 2027 choose it for you
A repair is typically $429 to $959+, against $2,489 to $3,589+ for a new tank installed. A $600 repair on a six-year-old tank is good money. The same repair on a fourteen-year-old tank is usually a deposit on the inevitable.
How old is it?
Look at the rating plate on the side of the tank. Some state the manufacture date outright. Most encode the year and the month or week in the serial number, in a format that differs by brand, so look up the brand's serial number format. The installation date is often written on the tank in marker, or on the permit sticker.
Make it last
- Flush it yearly. Draining a few buckets from the drain valve carries sediment out before it hardens.
- Have the anode checked. It is a sacrificial rod that corrodes so the tank does not. Replacing it is cheap next to a tank.
- Fix a dripping relief valve properly. It is telling you about pressure. An expansion tank is usually the cure.
- Keep the area clear. A gas heater needs air, and you need to reach the shut-offs.
Questions
Is it worth repairing a 10 year old water heater?
For a small repair, sometimes. At 10 years a gas tank is into the back half of its typical life, so weigh the repair against how soon you will be buying a new one anyway, and whether replacing it now keeps a rebate available.
Why is my hot water rusty but my cold water clear?
The rust is coming from the heater. Either the anode rod is used up and the tank has started to corrode, or the lining is already failing. On a young tank a new anode may stop it. On an old one, start planning the replacement.
Can a water heater explode?
A working relief valve makes that extremely unlikely, which is why it must never be capped, plugged or removed. If the relief valve is discharging hot water or steam, turn the heater off and call a plumber.
Sources
More water heater help
This page is general information, not professional advice for your home. Gas, electrical and plumbing work is regulated in British Columbia. If you are unsure at any point, stop and call a licensed contractor. See the legal disclaimer.