A guide from Pure Mechanical GroupWritten by a Red Seal plumber in British Columbia

Choosing · Lifespan and efficiency · Updated November 2026

Tank, tankless or heat pump.

The numbers for each type side by side, then the part the brochures skip: what each one needs from your house.

Side by side

TypeFuelEfficiencyAverage life
ENERGY STAR storage tankGas0.67 to 0.82 UEF10 to 13 years
Condensing storage tankGas0.80 to 0.89 UEF12 to 15 years
Non-condensing tanklessGas0.82 to 0.88 UEF20 years
Condensing tanklessGas0.89 to 0.97 UEF20 years
Standard storage tankElectric0.86 to 0.90 EF10 to 12 years
Heat pump water heaterElectric2.3 to 3.0 UEF13 years

Figures from FortisBC. UEF is the Uniform Energy Factor: the share of the energy going in that comes out as hot water. A heat pump scores above 1 because it moves heat instead of making it.

Storage tank

COLD INHOT OUT

The default for good reason. It is the least expensive to install, any plumber can service it, and a like-for-like replacement is usually done in a morning.

What it needs

  • A vent that suits it. Gas tanks come in three kinds. Natural draft vents up a chimney. Power vent uses a fan and plastic pipe through a wall. Direct vent is sealed and draws its air from outside. Replace like with like unless you are deliberately changing.
  • A chimney that still works. If a high-efficiency furnace has been installed since the tank went in, the tank may now be alone on a chimney sized for two appliances. That can cause poor draft and may call for a liner.
  • Floor space and a drain nearby.

The trade-offs

It can run out, and it burns energy all day keeping water hot. Natural Resources Canada says an ENERGY STAR gas tank saves about 9% over a standard one.

Tankless

COLDGASHOTVENT

Heats water as it passes through, so there is no tank to empty. Natural Resources Canada puts the saving for an ENERGY STAR tankless model at about 30% against a standard storage tank, and FortisBC puts its life at about 20 years.

What it needs

  • More gas. At full fire a whole-home tankless heater uses several times the gas of a tank. The gas line often has to be upsized.
  • Its own vent. A sealed vent through an outside wall or the roof. It cannot share the old tank's chimney.
  • A drain and an outlet. Condensing models make acidic condensate that has to be drained, and nearly all models need power, so most will not run in an outage.
  • A yearly flush. FortisBC's service list for tankless heaters includes flushing the heat exchanger to remove hard-water deposits.

The trade-offs

Hot water takes a few seconds longer to arrive. It will not run out, but it can be outrun: Natural Resources Canada notes a tankless heater may not keep up with several showers at once. Sizing matters more than with a tank.

Heat pump

WARM AIR INCOOL AIR OUT

An electric tank with a small heat pump on top. Natural Resources Canada says an ENERGY STAR model uses up to 50% less energy on average than a standard electric water heater, and that they are cost effective in mild climates, which describes the south coast.

What it needs

  • Air. It pulls heat out of the room, so it needs a good volume of air around it or ducting. Manufacturers typically ask for around 700 cubic feet. A small sealed closet will not do.
  • A condensate drain. It wrings water out of the air as it runs.
  • Headroom. The heat pump sits on top, so these are taller than the tank they replace.
  • An electrical circuit. Most are 240 volt. Replacing gas means running a new circuit, and checking the panel has room.

The trade-offs

It cools and dehumidifies the room it is in, which is welcome in a garage in July and less so in a finished basement in January. It makes about as much noise as a dehumidifier. It reheats more slowly than gas, so it is usually sized up a step.

Which one, quickly

Your tank just failedThe same type of tank. It is the fastest way back to hot water. In the City of Vancouver from 2027, see the rule first.
You run out of hot waterA larger tank, or tankless if the gas line and venting allow it.
You heat water with electricityA heat pump water heater, if you have the space and a drain. This is where the rebates are.
You are in a Vancouver house or duplexElectric or heat pump from January 1, 2027. The rule.
You may sell within a few yearsA standard tank. You will not be there for the payback.

Questions

Does a tankless water heater give instant hot water?

No. It gives endless hot water, not instant. The heater takes a few seconds to fire, and the water still has to travel the length of the pipe to the tap. A recirculation line is what shortens the wait.

Can a heat pump water heater go where my gas tank is?

Often, if the room is big enough or can be ducted, there is somewhere for condensate to drain, the ceiling is high enough, and a 240 volt circuit can be run to it. A cramped closet is the usual obstacle.

Which type is cheapest to run?

A heat pump water heater uses the least energy by a wide margin. What that means on your bill depends on your gas and electricity rates and how much hot water you use.

Sources

More water heater help

This page is general information, not professional advice for your home. Gas, electrical and plumbing work is regulated in British Columbia. If you are unsure at any point, stop and call a licensed contractor. See the legal disclaimer.