Choosing · Fuel · Updated November 2026
Gas or electric.
For most homes the answer is whatever you have now. Here is when it is worth changing, and what changing involves.
By Andrew HendersonRed Seal Plumber
Side by side
| Gas tank | Electric tank | Heat pump water heater | |
|---|---|---|---|
| To install | The baseline | About $400 less | About $3,000 more |
| To run, each month | The baseline | The same, up to $9 more | $15 to $27 less |
| What it needs | A gas line, a vent and combustion air | A 240 volt circuit | A 240 volt circuit, air around it and a drain |
| Reheats | Fastest | Slower | Slowest |
| Average life | 10 to 13 years | 10 to 12 years | About 13 years |
| Rebates | Income qualified only, condensing models | None | $1,000, and more if income qualified |
Install and running costs are the City of Vancouver's 2023 comparison by RDH Building Science, for a family of four, measured against a conventional 40 gallon gas tank at about $2,100 installed and $25 a month to run. Prices have moved since 2023, so read them as the gap between types, not as today's price. The figures that favour electric most assume a carbon tax of $170 a tonne. Lifespans are from FortisBC.
If you have gas now
Replacing gas with gas is the quickest and usually the least expensive job: the gas line, the vent and the space are already right for it. It is the sensible choice when the tank has just failed and you need hot water today.
It is worth pricing a change when the old vent is a problem. If your tank shares a chimney with a furnace that has since been replaced by a high-efficiency model, the tank may be alone on a chimney sized for two appliances, and that may call for a liner. At that point the cost of staying with gas goes up, and electric or heat pump is worth a look.
Switching from gas to electric
| A new circuit | An electric or heat pump water heater typically needs its own 240 volt circuit run from the panel. |
|---|---|
| Room in the panel | The panel needs space for the breaker and the service needs capacity for the load. An older 100 amp service that already feeds electric heat, a range and a dryer may need work first. An electrician checks this before you commit. |
| The gas line | Capped at the heater under a gas permit. The meter stays if anything else in the house uses gas. |
| The vent | Disconnected and closed off. If a furnace still uses the same chimney, it has to be checked on its own. |
| A bigger tank | Electric elements reheat more slowly than a gas burner, so the electric tank is usually one size up. What size you need. |
| Permits | Electrical for the wiring, gas for the capping, and in some cities plumbing as well. |
In a City of Vancouver pilot with BC Hydro, ten homes that replaced gas water heaters averaged $2,650 for an electric tank and $4,240 for a heat pump water heater, before rebates. What a heat pump water heater costs.
If you have electric now
Stay electric. Bringing gas to a heater that never had it means a gas line, a vent through the wall or roof, and in some houses a new gas service, all to install the type of heater that has no rebate. If the bill is the concern, a heat pump water heater is the upgrade: it uses up to half the energy of a standard electric tank, according to Natural Resources Canada, and it is where the rebates are.
When the power goes out
A gas tank with a standing pilot and a natural-draft vent keeps heating without electricity. Power-vent gas tanks, tankless heaters, electric tanks and heat pump water heaters all stop. A full tank of any kind stays warm for hours if you leave it alone, so a tank gives you some hot water in an outage and a tankless heater gives you none.
In the City of Vancouver
From January 1, 2027, a replacement water heater in a Vancouver house or duplex must be at least 100% efficient, which in practice means electric or heat pump. A conventional gas tank will not qualify. Homes with electrical or space constraints may qualify for an exception. The 2027 rule, explained.
Which one, quickly
| Gas now, tank just failed | Gas again, unless you are in a Vancouver house or duplex after January 1, 2027. |
|---|---|
| Gas now, tank still working, staying put | Price a heat pump water heater while the rebates still apply to you. |
| Gas now, vent or chimney problem | Compare the cost of fixing the vent with the cost of going electric. |
| Electric now | Electric again, or a heat pump water heater if you have the space and a drain. |
| You need hot water in a power outage | A natural-draft gas tank. |
Questions
Is a gas or electric water heater cheaper to run in B.C.?
They are close. The City of Vancouver's 2023 comparison puts a standard electric tank at the same cost as a conventional gas tank or up to $9 a month more for a family of four. A heat pump water heater is the cheapest to run, at about $15 to $27 a month less than a gas tank.
Can I switch from a gas water heater to an electric one?
Yes. It needs a 240 volt circuit and room in the electrical panel, the gas line is capped under a gas permit, and the old vent is closed off. In a City of Vancouver pilot, ten homes that made the switch averaged $2,650 for an electric tank before rebates.
Do gas water heaters work when the power is out?
A gas tank with a standing pilot and a natural-draft vent does. Power-vent gas tanks and tankless heaters need electricity and stop, as do electric and heat pump water heaters.
Sources
- City of Vancouver, Shape Your City: Hot water at home, questions and answers (cost table by RDH Building Science, 2023)
- City of Vancouver: Hot water at home, time-of-replacement questions and answers (PDF)
- FortisBC: Tank or tankless? How to find your perfect match in a water heater
- Natural Resources Canada: Guide to residential water heaters
- CleanBC Better Homes: Electric heat pump water heater rebate
- FortisBC: Natural gas water heater rebates, income qualified
- Technical Safety BC: Making gas or electrical changes to your home
More water heater help
This page is general information, not professional advice for your home. Gas, electrical and plumbing work is regulated in British Columbia. If you are unsure at any point, stop and call a licensed contractor. See the legal disclaimer.